KC Bakes - Cake Pop Queries (2024)

Cake Pop Questions

Hi everyone! It's Kim, from KC Bakes. We receive a lot of cake pop questions on our

Facebook page

, so I wanted to compile a list of cake pop frustrations that we all experience, and share what I've learned along the way.If I don't know the answer, I'll definitely find it out for you.

Why do my cake pops keep cracking?
Crackingthe #1 cake pop mystery. Generally, it's a temperature issue -the cake balls are too cold and the melted candy is too hot. Some bakers like to chill their cake pops in the freezer, and use mini Crock pots or double boilers to keep their chocolate hot - this can create an extreme difference in temperature. When I make cake pops, I keep my cake balls in the refrigerator and use the microwave instructions on the candy melt bag. Sometimes though, there is just no rhyme or reason.

My cake pops have air bubbles on them - how did that happen?
You arenot feel alone. For awhile, I was having THE worst time with air bubbles. They make your cake pops look lumpy, and can cause oil leaks (refer to next question below). The usual cause of air bubbles is stirring your chocolate too fast, by using more of a whipping method, or from over-stirring. I use a regular metal spoon to stir my candy melts with slow & steady strokes.

One thing that has really helped me with this problem is switching to CandiQuik. Their chocolate comes in one block and in its own tray. Traditionally when you melt other brands chocolate discs, it involves quite a bit of stirring because you have to keep stopping the microwave every 30 seconds, for quite a few minutes - hence, the air bubbles. But what I've come to really like about CandiQuik is that you put the tray in the microwave for 1-2 minutes, and you're done. Since switching, I have not had air bubble problems - not once!

Why is my chocolate is so thick - what do I do?
The Problem:

  • Over heating. If using the microwave, be sure to follow the instructions and heat them at 30 second intervals, and not for one long time period. If using a double-boiler, be mindful of your heat settings and keep the chocolate moving to avoid hot spots.
  • Brand. Everyone has their preferred brand, but Ialmost every bag of Wilton's candy melts that I've purchased have resulted in a thick, gloppy mess.I'm partial to Make'n Mold, and I've also heard great things about Merken's.
  • Color. For some reason, red melts (in any brand) aregenerally thick.

Solutions:

  • Brand. As mentioned in the previous query, I've started using CandiQuik. The melting process is much quicker and it produces a great consistency for cake pop making.
  • Oil orCrisco. Try stirring these into the thick chocolate and work them through thoroughly.If you find yourself adding a large amount, your batch of chocolate may be beyond help and it might be more effective to start over.
  • Paramount crystals.I haven't used these myself, but have heard from bakers that swear by them.

REMEMBER:When adding anything to your chocolate, recite these three words: less is more. You can always add more, but its impossible to subtract excess out.

When I dip the balls, they start to come off the stick. I tried dipping the sticks in chocolate before sticking them in the cake ball, but Istill have the same problem. Help!
Dipping the sticks in chocolate before inserting them in the cake ball is an important step, you're on the right track. Theimportant step here is to keepthe cake balls chilled, otherwise they will soften up and fall apart when they're dipped in the chocolate. Here's what I do when I make cake pops:

  • Place cake balls on small dessert plates (10 balls per plate), and place them all in the fridge.
  • One plate out at a time, insert the chocolate-dipped sticks in the cake balls, then put them back in.
  • When you're ready to dip them, pull out one plate at a time anddip those 10.
  • This method helps the majority of your cake balls to remain chilled during the dipping process.

Another problem can be the size/weight of the cake ball itself. If its particularly large, or really dense, this can cause the cake to fall off the stick as well.

Why is there condensation on my cake pops?
This is a common result of using frozen cake balls. In order to make cake pops, the cake balls need to be thawed out - but sometimes it is hard to tell if they are 100% thawed before dipping them. So as the chocolate exterior hardens, and the interior cake ball comes to room temperature, this causes the pop to "sweat".

Condensation is also a result of refrigerated finished pops. Whenever someone picks up cake pops from me, I advise them to store them at room temperature, usually on their kitchen counter. Note: I live in New Jersey, so I'm not sure how areas with more extreme weather conditions handle this issue.

Why are my cake pops leaking oil?
With my air bubble issues that I mentioned above, I also had the worst time with leaking pops. When chocolate hardens, it contracts. So, if there are air bubbles on the surface of your cake pop, they will break open when the chocolate dries, creating smallholes & exposing your cake ball underneath. Even if its a tiny pin-hole, oil will still be able to seep out of it. To fix this, dry off your finished cake pop and use melted chocolate to "plug" the hole.

Cake pops also leak oil if the cake itself is particularly wet. This can be a result of adding too much frosting, or by using a really dense cake recipes that call for a lot of eggs or oil (chocolate cake seems to give me the worst leaking problems).

Have you seen the commercials for cake pop cake pans? Do they work?
I'll fully admit I'm a bit of a cake-pop-snob when it comes to these pans/makers. They simply create dry balls of cake - there is no frosting involved in the process, so I'm not sure how they stay on the stick in the commercials (TV magic?). A friend made "cake pops" using one of these makers, and to be perfectly honest, it tasted like a stale donut-hole... it was dry in the center, and the chocolate exterior made it tough to eat because there was zero moisture. Just my humble opinion here - some people love them. Let me know what you think on this one :)

Have a Question?

Email your question to KC Bakes - kcbakes@hotmail.com :-)

These cake pop questions were posted on our Facebook page, and bakers gave their feedback. Check it out.

KC Bakes - Cake Pop Queries (2024)

FAQs

Why is there oil coming out of my cake pops? ›

Cake pops also leak oil if the cake itself is particularly wet. This can be a result of adding too much frosting, or by using a really dense cake recipes that call for a lot of eggs or oil (chocolate cake seems to give me the worst leaking problems).

Should you freeze or refrigerate cake pops before dipping? ›

Using the fridge can help avoid cracking issues when the pops are dipped. Generally, cracking is due to a temperature issue – the cake balls are too cold and the melted candy is too hot.

How long should I leave cake pops in the freezer? ›

Wrapped cake pops can sit in your refrigerator for up to one week or freezer for up to one month. If you were feeling fancy and broke out your vacuum sealer, your cake pops will stay fresh for several months in the freezer.

Should you skip the oil when making cake pops? ›

Make sure you pick a mix that calls for 3 eggs. Substitute the oil and water in the directions with 1 cup (250 ml) of milk and 1 stick (½ cup or 125 ml) of butter, melted. The use of oil in the cake will cause your cake pops to heavily ooze oil in certain instances and the sticks will yellow severely.

What not to do when making cake pops? ›

Don't make your cake balls too big or they may fall apart when you dip them. Do scoop and form only a few portions at a time. It'll help prevent your dough from drying out. Don't keep the unformed dough exposed to air (again, it will dry out).

Why do my cake pops fall apart when I dip them? ›

Make sure that your chocolate/candy melt is in a container that is deep enough for you to simply dip your pop into and cover completely! Moving your stick around in the chocolate/candy melt while dipping will cause your cake pops to fall apart. Dip and manipulate as little as possible!

Why are my cake pops falling off the stick? ›

Going overboard can cause your cake balls to fall of the sticks. The best rule of thumb is to start out with a small amount of icing and slowly add more until your mix reaches the consistency of clay. In my basic cake pop recipes, I use 1/3 to 1/2 cup of frosting.

What is the best chocolate to use for dipping cake pops? ›

Use good quality chocolate candy melts for dipping to ensure a smooth and glossy finish. Or, melt chocolate chips with a little bit of coconut oil. This allows the coating to harden and firm up.

Is it better to use candy melts or chocolate for cake pops? ›

For a more grown-up and luxurious form of cake pop, you can use melted chocolate instead of candy melts. Using chocolate with a high cacao content will give your cake pops depth of flavour that's not overruled by sweetness.

Can cake pops go bad? ›

How Long Do Cake Pops Last? Keep them in a cool and dry place on your counter, and they'll stay yummy for about a week. Throwing them in the fridge can extend their lifespan to 2 weeks or 1 month. Oh, and when chilling in the freezer, they can sit around for a whopping 3 months!

How to make cake pops that don't fall apart? ›

Food Network recommends dipping the sticks in the candy before pushing them into the cake balls. Once you've done this step for every cake pop, return them to the fridge or freezer to allow the candy to set. The candy, once dried, acts as a glue between the stick and the cake, helping hold them together.

How to make cake pops less oily? ›

The cake can also be very oily, causing oil to seep out the coating and even down the lollipop stick. If this happens, remember, you can always substitute apple sauce or greek yogurt for oil in your cake recipe! Using less frosting = less oil.

Why is my cake bringing out oil? ›

Greasy cakes are normally just the product of too much butter or fat being used to coat the cake tin. When the mixture is in the lined tin in the oven, the fat fries the sponge so cakes can often come out crispy around the edges or a little greasy on top.

What happens if you add too much frosting to cake pops? ›

Tricks to making homemade cake pops!

Most cakes are already moist. Too much frosting, and you have soggy, mushy, fall-apart cake pops. A little frosting goes a long way.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Last Updated:

Views: 6278

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (53 voted)

Reviews: 84% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner

Birthday: 1994-06-25

Address: Suite 153 582 Lubowitz Walks, Port Alfredoborough, IN 72879-2838

Phone: +128413562823324

Job: IT Strategist

Hobby: Video gaming, Basketball, Web surfing, Book restoration, Jogging, Shooting, Fishing

Introduction: My name is Rev. Porsche Oberbrunner, I am a zany, graceful, talented, witty, determined, shiny, enchanting person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.