Is V-Day OK? Experts weigh in on whether Valentine's Day celebrations for kids are objectifying or appropriate (2024)

Valentine's Day means something different to everyone, but most would agree the holiday is traditionally devoted to the celebration of romantic love.

Still, with pink and red hearts and bright boxes of candy covering shops across the globe in preparation for the day, it's no surprise that children long to get in on the fun. But is Valentine's Day OK for kids to celebrate?

Is the holiday for heart-shaped candy and flowers adorable and harmless? Or, are some V-Day celebrations objectifying and inappropriate?

Christine Michel Carter, a single mom and author from Baltimore, Md., says rather than focus on romantic love, she sees Valentine's Day as an opportunity to teach her kids about love and respect, as well as to debunk gender roles.

"I believe it's important to teach my children how to treat someone they care about," Michel Carter shares, "and not just from a romantic perspective."

To do this, Michel Carter developed her own version of the holiday to celebrate with her kids: "palentine's day." On "palentine's day," Michel Carter treats her kids to a meal at a high-end restaurant, something she describes as a fun way to teach them about manners and behavior in upscale locations. She also emphasizes to her kids that these experiences are not limited just to romantic partners of the opposite sex.

"I wanted to debunk gender roles and show my children a woman can pay for a fancy meal," she says. "This was especially important to me as the mother of a straight son and non-binary pansexual tween girl."

Pareen Sehat, a clinical counselor at Well Beings Counselling in Vancouver, Canada, says with a bit of planning, Valentine's Day can be a sweet celebration appropriate for all ages.

"It's a day that should be celebrated regardless of whether the individuals are seniors or teenagers," Sehat tells Yahoo Life. "The holiday is perfectly OK as it's a celebration of love. Valentine's Day is an all-inclusive day that doesn't differentiate between the gender of partners."

Abby Anoff lives in the United Kingdom and blogs about parenting at Kin Unplugged. Anoff says although her kids, a 3-year-old daughter and 6-month-old son, may still be young, she already has plans for how she hopes to share Valentine's Day with them as they grow.

"I'm perfectly happy for my [daughter] to celebrate [Valentine's Day] because at her age, I can control the narrative," says Anoff. "This year, I intend to teach her that Valentine's Day is about showing love to others the same way you would every other day, except that some people choose to exchange gifts on this day to signify that love."

Anoff says from an early age, she has shown her daughter and son that Valentine's Day represents all kinds of love. "It's important they know this showcase of love is not gender-based or romantic only," she explains.

But, while parents and experts agree that Valentine's Day can be harmless fun and even an opportunity to teach children something new, many are less-than-thrilled with the stereotypes and expectations that come with the day thanks to places like the kids' clothing section or candy aisle.

"I believe that stereotypes such as 'lady killer' and 'heart-breaker' add a negative connotation to the eventful day," says Sehat. "In a patriarchal society, these terms can damage the perspectives of individuals, as they feel that their ego is at stake every time a girl says, 'no.'"

Elizabeth Hicks, a mother of two and co-founder of the website Parenting Nerd, says while she supports children celebrating the holiday, she agrees it's time for some gender-specific stereotypes to come to an end. She's found that engaging in open, honest and age-appropriate conversations is a great way to dispel these negative tropes.

"Having any kind of conversation with your teenager is a challenge in itself, especially one revolving around love, sex and consent." says Hicks. "The best way to go about it is to be direct and use your own experiences in life to set an example."

Sehat concurs. "Every parent should have an age-appropriate conversation with their children about boundaries, consent and romantic love," she says.

While changing up the way Valentine's Day is celebrated in your home may seem like a great deal of preparation for one day, Hicks reminds parents that the day is a small holiday that brings attention to a larger picture: The romantic and platonic love Valentine's Day celebrates are an important part of our human experience and should be talked about with kids no matter which day of the year it is.

"Dating is a major aspect of our lives and everybody has to go through the experience once in their life," says Hicks. "Valentine's Day is a significant event that celebrates love and I believe everyone should be a part of it."

Want lifestyle and wellness news delivered to your inbox? Sign up here for Yahoo Life’s newsletter.

Is V-Day OK? Experts weigh in on whether Valentine's Day celebrations for kids are objectifying or appropriate (2024)

FAQs

What is the dark truth about Valentine's Day? ›

One Valentine was a priest in third-century Rome who defied Emperor Claudius II after the ruler outlawed marriage for young men. St. Valentine would perform marriages in secret for young lovers, ultimately leading to his death.

Should children celebrate Valentine's Day? ›

"The holiday is perfectly OK as it's a celebration of love. Valentine's Day is an all-inclusive day that doesn't differentiate between the gender of partners."

Why should you not celebrate Valentine's Day? ›

Valentine's Day also puts unnecessary pressure on a new or unstable relationship. If in a romantic relationship, Valentine's Day may lead to feeling obligated to make a serious investment or declaration of caring to your partner before you are ready.

Why is Valentine's Day controversial? ›

Despite the rich history surrounding Valentine's Day, today, this celebration is not without controversies. Some argue that the festivity has been excessively commercialized, becoming an occasion where consumerism prevails over the true essence of love and friendship.

What does the Bible say about Valentine's Day? ›

1 John 4:7-12. Dear friends: let us love one another, for love comes from God. Everyone who loves has been born of God and knows God. Whoever does not love does not know God, because God is love.

Should Christians celebrate Valentine's Day? ›

If that works for you, do it. But the biblical pattern teaches us that romantic love between husband and wife should be on display often and much. It isn't that celebrating Valentine's Day is too much; it is too little and weak. Christians, live your married years so that you don't need Valentine's Day.

Should a 10 year old have a Valentine? ›

Yes, giving your child a Valentine's Day card or treat is a lovely thing to do. Those who include their children in Valentine's Day tend to go all out on presents and special meals and messages of caring and kindness. "We have little presents and special dinner," says Stephanie M.

Is Valentine's day for kids or adults? ›

While adults tend to focus on romantic expressions of love, the 14th of February is also a great time of year to focus on how we all—children, too—can show compassionate love and kindness to our friends and family.

Why are people against Valentine's Day? ›

The traditions of Valentine's Day bring strong feelings, both for and against. Do you appreciate a cute tradition? Or do you hold it in contempt as a consumerist scam? Critics have blamed it for upholding a narrow-minded model of relationships as heterosexual and monogamous.

What should you not say on Valentine's Day? ›

Valentine's Day is celebrated around the world on February 14.
  • "I can't wait to have your babies."
  • 2. " Roses are red violets are blue...."
  • "I have to cancel."
  • 4. " ...
  • "I think we should see other people."
  • "I love you... even though you have gotten older/ fatter/ frumpier."
  • "I don't care about Valentine's Day."
Feb 14, 2020

Why is Valentine's Day banned in some countries? ›

But in some other countries like Indonesia, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia, the day is banned due to the day's conflicting views with the Islamic culture. Since 2009, certain practices pertaining to Valentine's Day (such as giving flowers, cards, or other gifts suggestive of Valentine's Day) are banned in Iran.

What is the dark history of Valentine's Day? ›

On February 14, around the year A.D. 270, Valentine, a priest in Rome in the days of Emperor Claudius II, is said to have been executed. Because he was marrying people, after the Emperor explicitly said he wanted the men to fight wars, not marry (Claudius actually banned Marriage for this very reason).

What are the criticism of Valentine's Day? ›

While Valentine's Day is a popular and widely celebrated holiday, it is not without its critics. Some people believe that the holiday is overly commercialized, promotes unhealthy relationship expectations, and excludes those who are single.

Why are some cultures opposed to Valentine's Day? ›

Valentine's Day has its roots in a Roman fertility celebration, but later evolved into a Christian feast day - a fact that worries conservatives in some Muslim-majority countries. In Indonesia's second-largest city, Surabaya, pupils were told to reject the festival as it runs against cultural norms.

What is the real story behind Valentine's Day? ›

Saint Valentine was discovered and imprisoned in a torture-ridden Roman jail, where he fell in love with a mysterious girl (believed to be his prosecutor's daughter). He sent her a love letter signed 'from your Valentine' right before his execution, thus originating the romantic sign-off still widely used today.

What is the deeper meaning of Valentine's Day? ›

It originated as a Christian feast day honoring a martyr named Valentine, and through later folk traditions it has also become a significant cultural, religious and commercial celebration of romance and love in many regions of the world.

What is the black code in Valentine's Day? ›

Black: Healing from a Rejected Proposal

Black might be a favourite of many, but on Valentine's Day, it symbolizes rejection. You just got your heart broken because of a rejected proposal. Wear a black outfit to portray your state of mind.

What did Valentine do secretly? ›

There are many other legends behind Saint Valentine. One is that in the 3rd century AD it is said that Valentine, who was a priest, defied the order of the emperor Claudius and secretly performed Christian weddings for couples, allowing the husbands involved to escape conscription into the pagan army.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Chrissy Homenick

Last Updated:

Views: 6302

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Chrissy Homenick

Birthday: 2001-10-22

Address: 611 Kuhn Oval, Feltonbury, NY 02783-3818

Phone: +96619177651654

Job: Mining Representative

Hobby: amateur radio, Sculling, Knife making, Gardening, Watching movies, Gunsmithing, Video gaming

Introduction: My name is Chrissy Homenick, I am a tender, funny, determined, tender, glorious, fancy, enthusiastic person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.