How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (2024)

Our friend Catherine De Orio is a chef, national food expert, and dining show host. Aren’t we lucky? She’s a great person to know when it comes to kitchen tips and tricks. Here, she fills us in on a few semi-homemade secrets. Read on to find out how to make jar pasta sauce taste even better (like you made it from scratch)!

I love tomato sauce. Coming from an Italian-American family, the smell of tomato sauce, or “gravy” in my family, simmering all day on the Sunday stove brings back fond memories of time spent at home with my loved ones. These days, we are all so busy, finding the time to spend with them is difficult—let alone finding time to let sauce simmer for hours! Here are 10 steps for giving a jar of store-bought spaghetti sauce a taste of home.

What you'll need

  • Jarred spaghetti sauce
  • Large pan
  • Spoon or spatula
  • Onions
  • Garlic
  • Olive oil
  • Crushed red pepper
  • Your choice of herbs (basil, oregano, rosemary, bay leaf)
  • “Savory” vegetables, such as mushrooms
  • Hunt’s® tomato paste
  • Your choice of cheese (Parmesan, pecorino, ricotta)
  • Your choice of meat (beef, veal, pork, lamb, neck bones)
  • Your choice of wine (we like Sangiovese)

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (1)

Step 1: Build A Flavorful Foundation

Everything tastes better with some sautéed garlic and onions. Sauté finely chopped onions and garlic in olive oil until fragrant and golden, then add the sauce and let it simmer so the flavors can meld together.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (3)

Step 3: Go Green

Add fresh herbs (basil, oregano, rosemary, bay leaf), and let them simmer to give a punch of fresh flavor.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (4)

Step 4: Veg Out

Since many jarred sauces have sugar in them, I lean toward more savory vegetables—think mushrooms, not carrots. Be sure to brown the veggies a bit to help bring out their flavors, and then add to sauce.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (5)

Step 5: Thicken It Up

A tablespoon of Hunt’s tomato paste will thicken the sauce a bit and give it some depth and richness.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (6)

Step 6: Add Body With Pasta Water

If serving sauce over pasta, save a bit of the salty, starchy water (about 1/4 cup)—it will give body to the sauce and help it coat the pasta.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (7)

Step 7: More Cheese, Please

Add the rind from a piece of Parmesan cheese while simmering the sauce to add a bit of nutty, salty flavor. Before serving, grate high-quality Parmesan or pecorino cheese over the dish. Want something heartier? Spoon in a couple tablespoons of ricotta cheese for a rich and creamy tomato sauce.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (8)

Step 8: Carnivore Cravings

Choose your favorite ground meat—I like a mix of beef, veal, and pork. Feel free to use lamb or neck bones too! Brown the meat, drain off any excess grease, and then add to sauce and let it simmer. While it simmers, skim off any grease that rises to the top.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (9)

Step 9: Wine About It

Take your favorite vino (I like to use a Sangiovese) and deglaze the pan after sautéing meat or vegetables so you can get all the tasty brown bits, known as fond, into your sauce. And pour yourself a glass while you're at it—I always find cooking more relaxing with some vino in hand!

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (10)

Step 10: Simmer Down Now

OK, so I know I said you don’t have to simmer sauce all day, but it should simmer a bit. You can cut the time down, however. A good 20- to 30-minute simmer will reward you with a much richer, flavorful sauce.

Pro Tip

Catherine De Orio is a dining show host, chef, and national food expert.

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade (2024)

FAQs

How to make jarred tomato sauce taste homemade? ›

A generous sprig or two of fresh herbs like basil, parsley, rosemary, or sage can all amp up the flavor of a jarred pasta sauce. Alternatively, some of those herbs, like parsley, sage, and rosemary, can be great minced up and gently fried into fresh olive oil before adding the sauce to the pot.

How do you upgrade jarred tomato sauce? ›

Pungent fresh herbs like thyme, rosemary, sage, tarragon, and marjoram can liven up tomato sauce with their bold, distinctive flavors. Add 1 to 2 sprigs of one or more of them to your favorite sauce, cover, and simmer at least 5 minutes to allow them to infuse in the sauce. Remove the sprigs before serving.

How to make canned tomato sauce taste better? ›

Enhance canned tomato sauce with these spices for a burst of flavor:
  1. Garlic Powder: Adds depth and savory notes. 🧄🍝
  2. Dried Oregano and Basil: Classic Italian herbs for aromatic richness. 🌿🇮🇹
  3. Red Pepper Flakes: Infuse a hint of heat for a dynamic kick. 🌶️🔥
  4. Onion Powder: Brings a subtle sweetness to the sauce. 🧅🍅
Oct 17, 2023

How do you make tomato sauce not taste like tomatoes? ›

While it may sound counterintuitive, adding a bit of acidity can actually help cut the tomato taste. A squeeze of lemon juice or a splash of vinegar can balance out the flavors and make the sauce taste more harmonious. Start with a small amount and taste as you go to achieve the desired balance.

Why does my homemade tomato sauce taste bitter? ›

Tomato sauce that has turned bitter due to overcooking can be remedied by adding sugar or baking soda to reduce the acidity. Adding sugar, butter, or cream might help cover the bitter flavor. Think about the variety and freshness of the tomatoes you use in your sauce and how that can affect the overall bitterness.

How do you doctor up store bought tomato sauce? ›

How to Make Jarred Tomato Sauce Better… And If You Even Should
  1. Start With a Good Jar.
  2. Add Alliums.
  3. Deglaze With Wine.
  4. Season Smartly.
  5. Whisk in Tomato Paste.
  6. Boost the Acidity.
  7. Toss in Olives or Capers.
  8. Add Vegetables.

How to make jar tomato sauce taste homemade? ›

Add fresh herbs (basil, oregano, rosemary, bay leaf), and let them simmer to give a punch of fresh flavor.

How to jazz up jarred spaghetti sauce? ›

Tossing in strips of basil, a sprig of thyme or some oregano can take your sauce to the next level. Although fresh herbs might pop a bit more, dried herbs and spices can work just as well. Sprinkling in some red pepper flakes, a pinch of parsley and a dash of salt and pepper can liven up your jarred pasta sauce.

How do you add depth of Flavour to tomato sauce? ›

"I like to add roasted garlic, fresh basil, and sautéed chopped veggies like mushrooms, bell pepper, and onion into my sauce. This combination gives it a garden-variety taste and feel," Chase told Insider. Sometimes they'll also add red chili flakes or a drizzle of garlic oil to the sauce.

Why doesn't my tomato sauce taste good? ›

Your spaghetti sauce may taste bland due to insufficient seasoning. Try adding more salt, herbs (like basil, oregano, or thyme), and other flavor enhancers like garlic, onion, or red pepper flakes. Also, a dash of sugar can balance flavors and bring out the natural sweetness of tomatoes.

Why does my homemade tomato sauce taste bland? ›

Flat or bland sauce likely needs a hit of something acidic to lift and enhance its flavors, such as a small splash of high-quality, flavorful vinegar, a squeeze of fresh lemon juice, or a few drops of not-too-fiery hot sauce.

What to add to store-bought spaghetti sauce? ›

8 Ways to Elevate Canned Spaghetti Sauce
  1. 1 - Extra virgin olive oil. Adding a good amount of a flavorful olive oil will go a long way in infusing flavor into your sauce. ...
  2. 2 - Fresh garlic. ...
  3. 3 - Meat. ...
  4. 4 - Hot pepper flakes. ...
  5. 5 - Red wine. ...
  6. 6 - Fresh or dried herbs. ...
  7. 7 - Cheese. ...
  8. 8 - Cream and/or butter.
Feb 26, 2018

Why does my homemade tomato sauce taste so acidic? ›

When you make home-made tomato sauce with fresh or tinned tomatoes, it can sometimes turn out to be too acidic. Add a little milk to tomato sauce for a sweeter taste to offset the acidity of the tomatoes. This is a well-kept secret amongst Italian grandmothers.

Does cooking tomato sauce longer make it taste better? ›

Tomato sauce deepens and intensifies the longer you cook it. Tomato sauces can be cooked in 10 minutes or for 4 hours, and they can all be delicious. Cooking sauces for a long time don't inherently make them better, but it does intensify the flavor.

What can I add to tomato sauce to make it less bitter? ›

Heat 1 cup of sauce with 1/4 teaspoon baking soda (baking soda neutralizes acidity). Taste the sauce and add tiny amounts of baking soda to see if it mellows the acidity. If there is still an edge, swirl in a teaspoon of butter, letting it melt until creamy. Usually this does the job.

What neutralizes bitter taste? ›

Sweetness: From sugar, honey, fruits or otherwise, sweetness will counteract bitter and sour flavours. It can also be used to cut down the heat of a particularly spicy meal. Saltiness: Salt plays two very important roles in flavouring a dish. Firstly, it balances against bitterness.

How do you make sauce from a jar better? ›

Tossing in strips of basil, a sprig of thyme or some oregano can take your sauce to the next level. Although fresh herbs might pop a bit more, dried herbs and spices can work just as well. Sprinkling in some red pepper flakes, a pinch of parsley and a dash of salt and pepper can liven up your jarred pasta sauce.

What spices can I add to store bought tomato sauce? ›

Red pepper flakes, dehydrated or fresh garlic, dried oregano, parsley, or basil, or an Italian seasoning blend are all good options. Dried herbs and spices should be added at the beginning of the cook time so that they have time to bloom.

What can you add to tomato sauce to make more? ›

Spruce up the sauce by using any or all of the following: red pepper flakes, fresh tomatoes or diced tomatoes, crushed tomatoes, olive oil, fresh basil or dried basil, grated Parmesan, a few minced garlic cloves or fresh chopped onions. Add sugar 1 teaspoon at a time for a sweeter sauce.

What is the secret to good tomato sauce? ›

5 Tips for a Better Tasting Tomato Sauce
  • Use wine. Both red and white wine work extremely well for adding flavor to tomato sauce. ...
  • Roast the tomatoes first. ...
  • Add a Parmesan or Romano rind. ...
  • Stir in a little butter. ...
  • Try anchovies.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kieth Sipes

Last Updated:

Views: 6209

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (47 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kieth Sipes

Birthday: 2001-04-14

Address: Suite 492 62479 Champlin Loop, South Catrice, MS 57271

Phone: +9663362133320

Job: District Sales Analyst

Hobby: Digital arts, Dance, Ghost hunting, Worldbuilding, Kayaking, Table tennis, 3D printing

Introduction: My name is Kieth Sipes, I am a zany, rich, courageous, powerful, faithful, jolly, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.